And now it’s time for another Geek Thoughts.

Here’s why I think all Earth-bound attempts at time travel are doomed to failure: Unless the time travel also involves some sort of spatial component, the time traveler is going to reappear in empty space. The Earth is in motion. The solar system is in motion. The galaxy is in motion. The universe is in motion.

By the time you finish reading this sentence, the Earth will have moved far beyond where it was located at the beginning of the sentence. If you were to travel back in time (or forward in time) just one minute, what is it that would keep you tethered to the Earth as opposed to some absolute location in the universal scheme of things, an absolute location essentially in empty space? (Or, at the very least, in the middle of an ocean.)

I’m not saying that time travel is impossible — though I believe that’s likely the case — I’m just saying that time travel is impractical, and isn’t likely to produce anything other than a bunch of space flotsam.

Teleportation, on the other hand, might be practical. If it’s instantaneous.

90 Replies to “The Trouble with Time Travel”

  1. Paul J. says:

    Or, you need to redefine your concept of time travel a bit.

    http://www.amazon.com/Yoga-Time-Travel-Mind-Defeat/dp/083560828X

    “Free your mind”…

  2. Dave says:

    Somehow I think that if we could figure out how to move along the time-stream we could probably also figure out the spacial coordinate problem that you’re referring to, thereby ensuring that we arrive not only WHEN we wanted to, but WHERE.

    On the other hand, this also depends on how you define time. If time is defined as the occurrence of specific events (or even the lack of said occurrence), then such a thing might be inherently linked to a specific locale as well. In other words, referencing something in the fourth dimension of space/time cannot be done without simultaneously referencing the other three dimensions, just like you can’t reference the third dimension of space without inherently referencing the other two.

  3. D says:

    The motion part is true, but you assume going back or forward in time will maintain your spatial location.

    I think that time and space are interlocked, so if you are on Earth and go back 1,000 years, you are also going back spatially 1,000 years.

    When you change your spatial parameters time changes along with it. The same would be true visa-versa.

  4. Jon says:

    Just bring your space ship along when you time travel.

  5. Karl Staib says:

    If you travel back in time wouldn’t you travel to where the planets were at that time?

  6. Interesting concept. We will just have to wait and see if it is plausible. Thanks for making me think.

  7. Mom says:

    Very well thought out, J.D. I personally don’t see how either time travel or teleportation are possible. But we are reaping the rewards these days of many inventions that were once deemed impossible, so I may be wrong on that, although I doubt it. 😉

    I am writing also to invite you to my blog, for a special reason, which you will see when you get there.

  8. B says:

    Is thursday beer night?

  9. Wesley Crusher says:

    JD’s thoughts on time travel are only applicable when there is a rift in the space/time continuum.

  10. OVGuillermo says:

    Thank you for your site. I have found here much useful information.
    Good site ! 😉

  11. Genqiala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://flufishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-alaska-fishing+-salmon-sockeye.php “> alaska alaska fishing+ salmon sockeye

  12. Genqiala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://flufishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-alaska-fishing+-salmon-sockeye.php “> alaska alaska fishing+ salmon sockeye

  13. Genqiala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://flufishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-alaska-fishing+-salmon-sockeye.php “> alaska alaska fishing+ salmon sockeye

  14. Genqiala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://flufishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-alaska-fishing+-salmon-sockeye.php “> alaska alaska fishing+ salmon sockeye

  15. Genqiala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://flufishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-alaska-fishing+-salmon-sockeye.php “> alaska alaska fishing+ salmon sockeye

  16. Genqiala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://flufishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-alaska-fishing+-salmon-sockeye.php “> alaska alaska fishing+ salmon sockeye

  17. Sanioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishii.freehostia.com/1/5/petersburg-alaska-halibut-fishing+.php “> petersburg alaska halibut fishing+

  18. Sanioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishii.freehostia.com/1/5/petersburg-alaska-halibut-fishing+.php “> petersburg alaska halibut fishing+

  19. Sanioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishii.freehostia.com/1/5/petersburg-alaska-halibut-fishing+.php “> petersburg alaska halibut fishing+

  20. Sanioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishii.freehostia.com/1/5/petersburg-alaska-halibut-fishing+.php “> petersburg alaska halibut fishing+

  21. Sanioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishii.freehostia.com/1/5/petersburg-alaska-halibut-fishing+.php “> petersburg alaska halibut fishing+

  22. Xifqoala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishingal.freehostia.com/1/3/charter-fishing+-florida-online.php “> charter fishing+ florida online

  23. Xifqoala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishingal.freehostia.com/1/3/charter-fishing+-florida-online.php “> charter fishing+ florida online

  24. Xifqoala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishingal.freehostia.com/1/3/charter-fishing+-florida-online.php “> charter fishing+ florida online

  25. Xifqoala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishingal.freehostia.com/1/3/charter-fishing+-florida-online.php “> charter fishing+ florida online

  26. Xifqoala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishingal.freehostia.com/1/3/charter-fishing+-florida-online.php “> charter fishing+ florida online

  27. Xifqoala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://fishingal.freehostia.com/1/3/charter-fishing+-florida-online.php “> charter fishing+ florida online

  28. Gupioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://alaskafishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-fishing+-salmon-southeast-sport.php “> alaska fishing+ salmon southeast sport

  29. Gupioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://alaskafishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-fishing+-salmon-southeast-sport.php “> alaska fishing+ salmon southeast sport

  30. Gupioala says:

    interesting thank you…
    http://alaskafishing.freehostia.com/1/3/alaska-fishing+-salmon-southeast-sport.php “> alaska fishing+ salmon southeast sport

  31. B says:

    Ah. . . you’ve torn a hole in the space time continuum. Poor Gupioala is stuck typing out fishing spam forever.

  32. Doc Brown says:

    Great Scott! Quick somebody get into the DeLorean and hide Kusoqala’s keyboard before he gets home!

  33. Doc Brown says:

    Great Scott! Quick somebody get into the DeLorean, go back in time and hide Kusoqala’s keyboard before he gets home!

  34. Wqkaota says:

    ultram without prescription
    http://pharma587.sinfree.net/ultram-without-prescription.html “>ultram without prescription

  35. Wqkaota says:

    ultram without prescription
    http://pharma587.sinfree.net/ultram-without-prescription.html “>ultram without prescription

  36. Wqkaota says:

    ultram without prescription
    http://pharma587.sinfree.net/ultram-without-prescription.html “>ultram without prescription

  37. WONUeuon says:

    I have seen all Internet. Do or die, guys!
    http://dominica.freehostzoo.com/16 “>tramadol

  38. WONUeuon says:

    I have seen all Internet. Do or die, guys!
    http://dominica.freehostzoo.com/16 “>tramadol

  39. TAwiquon says:

    sony p100 digital camera
    http://digitalcam.iespana.es/2 “>sony p100 digital camera

  40. TAwiquon says:

    sony p100 digital camera
    http://digitalcam.iespana.es/2 “>sony p100 digital camera

  41. Bivqyuon says:

    holiday villas in italy
    http://diets.funpic.org “>holiday villas in italy

  42. HUmOiuon says:

    insurance industry
    http://amino2.funpic.de “>insurance industry

  43. HUmOiuon says:

    insurance industry
    http://amino2.funpic.de “>insurance industry

  44. KyXAUuon says:

    LJLFSEREDSFDSFDSFFDSFTRTTSSGFSGF
    l

  45. HOgjquon says:

    LJLFSEREDSFDSFDSFFDSFTRTTSSGFSGF
    k

  46. SjTyqata says:

    celebrex lawyers allas
    http://celebrx.onlinewebshop.net/celeb25.html “>celebrex lawyers allas

  47. SjTyqata says:

    celebrex lawyers allas
    http://celebrx.onlinewebshop.net/celeb25.html “>celebrex lawyers allas

  48. SjTyqata says:

    celebrex lawyers allas
    http://celebrx.onlinewebshop.net/celeb25.html “>celebrex lawyers allas

  49. Xivjeata says:

    buy diazepa overnight
    http://diazepmm.66ghz.com/diaz22.html “>buy diazepa overnight

  50. Xivjeata says:

    buy diazepa overnight
    http://diazepmm.66ghz.com/diaz22.html “>buy diazepa overnight

  51. Xivjeata says:

    buy diazepa overnight
    http://diazepmm.66ghz.com/diaz22.html “>buy diazepa overnight

  52. Xivjeata says:

    buy diazepa overnight
    http://diazepmm.66ghz.com/diaz22.html “>buy diazepa overnight

  53. Cqgyeata says:

    ciprofloxacin farmakokinetik
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm21.html “>ciprofloxacin farmakokinetik

  54. Cqgyeata says:

    ciprofloxacin farmakokinetik
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm21.html “>ciprofloxacin farmakokinetik

  55. TUDjAata says:

    meridia hillcrest hospital
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm34.html “>meridia hillcrest hospital

  56. HOwAiata says:

    brand carisoprodol collins
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm2.html “>brand carisoprodol collins

  57. HOwAiata says:

    brand carisoprodol collins
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm2.html “>brand carisoprodol collins

  58. HOwAiata says:

    brand carisoprodol collins
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm2.html “>brand carisoprodol collins

  59. HOwAiata says:

    brand carisoprodol collins
    http://pharmfin.awardspace.com/pharm2.html “>brand carisoprodol collins

  60. Kyvjqata says:

    The most popular source of drug information online
    http://sspharm.usafreespace.com “>The most popular source of drug information online

  61. LifqUuon says:

    Na2011b11backs
    i

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Close Search Window